Picture books rate
![Picture](/uploads/5/0/8/7/50879547/5418775.gif?168)
-PICTURE BOOKS-
Picture Book Judging
Please rate your book according to the following Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA) criteria.
A maximum of 5 points can be given for each criterion.
Book #1 – Title / Author:
Frederick / Leo Lionni
Criterion Score (05) - 04
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: simple and cute, the color is similar in each page (about 10 color used)
Also it is simple but full of information because we can find that many characters doing different things.
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: We can understand each situation and feel comfortable with light colors.
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: easy to see for everyone
we can find that the character seems like moving.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: It's connected.
Sometimes the sentences are too many for reading, but some sentences are appeared
for the character's line with circling, so it is easy to read.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: The illustration is drawn consistently, so we can understand this picture book's view of the world.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: easy to understand
We can recognize each pictures as a character and things, for example the picture of mouse is a mouse, a cave is cave.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: Good and tough cover
It is a little bit simple for children.
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by
the above criteria) :
It's not for children because this content is a little bit difficult.
Picture Book Judging
Please rate your book according to the following Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA) criteria.
A maximum of 5 points can be given for each criterion.
Book #1 – Title / Author:
Frederick / Leo Lionni
Criterion Score (05) - 04
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: simple and cute, the color is similar in each page (about 10 color used)
Also it is simple but full of information because we can find that many characters doing different things.
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: We can understand each situation and feel comfortable with light colors.
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: easy to see for everyone
we can find that the character seems like moving.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: It's connected.
Sometimes the sentences are too many for reading, but some sentences are appeared
for the character's line with circling, so it is easy to read.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: The illustration is drawn consistently, so we can understand this picture book's view of the world.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: easy to understand
We can recognize each pictures as a character and things, for example the picture of mouse is a mouse, a cave is cave.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: Good and tough cover
It is a little bit simple for children.
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by
the above criteria) :
It's not for children because this content is a little bit difficult.
![Picture](/uploads/5/0/8/7/50879547/5638404.gif?201)
Book #2 – Title / Author:
Goodnight moon / Margaret Wise Brown
Criterion Score (05) 3.5
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: colorful and cute, used Christmas color
We can see whole room.
The outside can see the star light.
Wandering
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: changing the point of room's view
Perspective drawing
Impressive (A lot of different color tone)
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: Many Horizoned and vertical line are used (and also curved)
Fire's shape like a burning.
Texuture is image of sleeping.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: It's very connected.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: characterization and style is same in each page.
Sometimes this book changing the point of room's view.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: It's not so beautiful,but it's attractive for children because a lot of different art style.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: It's hard, it looks like expensive book.
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above
criteria): It's attractive for children.
Goodnight moon / Margaret Wise Brown
Criterion Score (05) 3.5
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: colorful and cute, used Christmas color
We can see whole room.
The outside can see the star light.
Wandering
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: changing the point of room's view
Perspective drawing
Impressive (A lot of different color tone)
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: Many Horizoned and vertical line are used (and also curved)
Fire's shape like a burning.
Texuture is image of sleeping.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: It's very connected.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: characterization and style is same in each page.
Sometimes this book changing the point of room's view.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: It's not so beautiful,but it's attractive for children because a lot of different art style.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: It's hard, it looks like expensive book.
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above
criteria): It's attractive for children.
![画像](/uploads/5/0/8/7/50879547/8147645.jpg?183)
Book #3 – Title / Author:
Lost and Found / Oliver Jeffers
Criterion Score (05) - 04
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: water color painting
We can feel scale.
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: shadow
Warmful atmosphere
Blight
Looks like real
Almost schenes were drawn from his eyes.
Sometimes express his feeling
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: Blight
Soft
His leg looks like stick.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: 1~2 sentences in each picture, so it is really matching each other.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: Not confused
Simple
All scnene has same style, but sometimes 2 pages are used for 1 sentence, so it is devided to simple and
large scale part along with the story.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: Probably we can't understand some shenes if there is no text. For example, the schene of boy's screaming and
penguin's sad face schene.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: not so hard cover
Flexible
We can read it easily
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above
criteria): We can read it easily because this picture book's cover is flexible and it is light.
We can feel reality of a story because of water color painting, so it is good for children.
Whole atmosphere is warm, but sometimes I feel lonely and scary.
Lost and Found / Oliver Jeffers
Criterion Score (05) - 04
Artistic style and graphic excellence
(including typography and its suitability for the implied readership)
Comments: water color painting
We can feel scale.
Effective use of media and technique
Comments: shadow
Warmful atmosphere
Blight
Looks like real
Almost schenes were drawn from his eyes.
Sometimes express his feeling
Color, line, shape, texture
Comments: Blight
Soft
His leg looks like stick.
Relationship between illustration and text
Comments: 1~2 sentences in each picture, so it is really matching each other.
Consistency of style, characterization, information and setting
Comments: Not confused
Simple
All scnene has same style, but sometimes 2 pages are used for 1 sentence, so it is devided to simple and
large scale part along with the story.
Clarity appropriateness and aesthetic appeal of illustrations
Comments: Probably we can't understand some shenes if there is no text. For example, the schene of boy's screaming and
penguin's sad face schene.
Quality of book design, production, printing and binding
Comments: not so hard cover
Flexible
We can read it easily
General Comments: (Including qualities or merits of the book not captured by the above
criteria): We can read it easily because this picture book's cover is flexible and it is light.
We can feel reality of a story because of water color painting, so it is good for children.
Whole atmosphere is warm, but sometimes I feel lonely and scary.